AnsweredAssumed Answered

Anonymously Graded Assignments Retain Anonymity after Posting Grades

Question asked by Linda J. Lee on Sep 19, 2019
Latest reply on Feb 25, 2020 by Linda J. Lee

Hi folks,


We've had several reports of something unexpected with anonymously graded assignments in New Gradebook. When grades are posted in New Gradebook, the assignment continues to hide grades in the gradebook and student names in SpeedGrader. Students, as expected, can see their grades after posting. Has anyone else seen this issue?


With anonymous grading, anonymity is in place during the grading process. SpeedGrader shows “Student 1,” “student 2,” etc. And the gradebook completely grays out the column. This changes when either anonymous grading is removed from the assignment, or when grades are unmuted in old gradebook or posted (for everyone, the only option) in New Gradebook.


We opened a case yesterday with Instructure support (case 04746925), and the L2 who responded to our case last night suggested that this is the expected behavior:

I would like to confirm on this case that you are looking to have the anonymity removed when grades are posted is this correct? Because the assignment is set up to be anonymous to graders it will remain this way as long as this setting is still enabled in the assignment settings.

However, this is not the behavior that we've seen in the past, nor is it what is explained in the documentation for anonymous grading or New Gradebook:


For anonymous grading (How do I add an assignment that includes anonymous grading?):


  • Unmuting or posting grades for an anonymous assignment will remove anonymity from the assignment.


For New Gradebook (How do I post grades for an assignment in the New Gradebook?):

  • Posting grades for an anonymous assignment will remove anonymity from the assignment.


Has anyone else seen this issue? If it is, in fact, the intended behavior, does anyone know when this change went into effect?