Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Spotlight on Five-Star Course Design

Spotlight on Five-Star Course Design

Want a chance to win some Canvas SWAG? I know Canvas SWAG is a coveted hopefully, I got your attention! 😉 Read on to learn more!

What’s Included in This Post?
• Course Examples of Five-Star Course Design


As educators, we want our students to have the best learning experience possible! What creates the optimal Canvas experience? I like to think of a Canvas course as an experience, similar to an experience you might have when visiting a hotel. Your experience at a budget inn will not likely not be the same as an all-inclusive resort, right? As an Instructional Designer, I’d like to share three best practices that I believe make the most considerable impact on student learning and help give students that state-of-the-art experience.

Welcoming Home Page and Consistent Elements

When visiting a hotel, your experience starts in the hotel foyer when you check-in, and it sets the stage for the experience to come (Do you feel welcomed? Does it look nice? Do you know where to go?) Thinking of your Canvas Home Page like a hotel foyer will help set the course’s tone and what’s to come! All that’s necessary to be effective is a visual welcome like a banner or other graphic or welcoming message, and a clear starting point for learners. 

Let me set your mind at ease…you do not have to know HTML or be a graphic designer to design an effective course!  I remember years ago seeing a full-page Nike ad in my local newspaper.  The entire page was white, and there was a tiny black Nike Swoosh in the center of the page.  I wondered why the page was so empty but realized that it caught my attention, and that was the point! It made me realize that sometimes SIMPLE IS BEST. Sometimes too much on your Home Page can be distracting or overwhelming to the student.

Below is an example of a Primary Home Page that sets the tone with a fun, adventure-themed Home Page.  Here you see one banner, a welcome message, and five buttons - it’s simple and easy to understand where to go to find things like a schedule or the daily activities. Graphics similar to these can easily be created using a free graphic software program like Canva!  If you need help learning Canva, I highly recommend the tutorials in Canva Design School!


When you visit a hotel, you see the branding, colors, and decor incorporated throughout the spaces. Carrying the same look and feel of your Home Page throughout the course in your pages and learning activities with consistent colors, layouts, and organization can help create an optimal experience for students! 

The screenshots below are from Apple’s Swift curriculum (take a look, these courses are free in Canvas Commons!)  Notice how clean and minimalistic the Home Page is and how that same look and feel is carried throughout the content pages and learning activities! Also, notice that the “feel” of this course is not the same as in the first adventure example, but each is equally effective in inviting a warm welcome and guiding the learner on where to go.


Course Navigation and Organization

Now, imagine being in a hotel and not knowing how to find your room, the elevator, pool, or restaurant. We never want students to feel lost in a course. I prefer to hide most of the Course Navigation and have learners access everything from the Modules area.  Think about your course objectives and think about how you will introduce the content.  Start your Module with a Canvas Page that gives an overview of the topic and what’s to come.  Then, start introducing your content to your learners.  Pages are a great way to present a variety of instructional materials.  In Pages, you can incorporate videos, articles, teacher-made resources, websites, and even tech tools to help build the foundation of learning.  Then, include learning activities that create meaningful interaction and engage learners to promote the achievement of your objectives (i.e., discussions, practice quizzes, assignments, etc.) 

Putting things in the order that you want students to encounter them and using Module Prerequisites and/or Requirements can keep students from skipping around and missing important content. With everything organized in Modules, students are less likely to get lost, which can make all the difference in your student experience. Looking at the course through Student View can also help you better understand the student experience.

Below is a snippet of a weekly module shared by Kern County Superintendent of Schools (KCSOS) in Bakersfield, California. Using Text Headers, indentions, and clear naming conventions can help students have a smooth course experience and limit frustrations. You might choose to use emojis to visually represent things within your Modules for young learners. In this module example, each day’s Live Instruction Page was intentionally left unpublished until the teacher added the daily recording to the page. Universal Design for Learning (UDL) principles like student choice, engagement, and expression, were also incorporated in this module. Hats off to my friends at KCSOS for their terrific work in supporting districts, teachers, and students!


Accessibility and Mobile-Friendliness

Now back to my hotel example - imagine if there wasn’t an elevator and you had to trek up 50 flights of stairs to get to your room. When designing a course, it’s essential to think about all learners and their ease of use. All students, regardless of variability, should learn. Building for accessibility and mobile-friendliness is critical.

In a past CanvasLIVE, Taking Your Canvas Course to the Next Level, Dr. Deonne Johnson walked through actual courses with teachers and showed how to make them accessible.  I highly recommend watching this CanvasLIVE if you’ve never seen it!  She explained that public places began installing wheelchair/curb ramps in the ’90s to comply with the Americans with Disability Act (ADA).  However, many people who don’t use wheelchairs are also thankful for those accommodations!  For example, if you are pulling your luggage or a stroller behind you as you enter the hotel, those ramps make your life much easier!  Designing well is advantageous to all learners!  Two fabulous resources to learn more about accessibility and mobile-friendliness are the General Accessibility Design Guidelines and the Mobile App Design | Course Evaluation Checklist

Our go-to resource for creating an overall quality Canvas course is the Course Evaluation Checklist v2.0, which Dr. Deonne Johnson used in the CanvasLIVE I recommended above. I love this checklist because it’s simple, easy to use, and based on research. It’s great because anyone can use it, no matter their subject area, grade level, or tech-savviness!   


Final Thoughts


How Many Stars Would Your Courses Earn?

After I stay in a hotel, I usually tell a few friends about my experience. I might even go online and complete a review to tell the world! Are you ready to share your courses with the Canvas Community? If you are, we want to feature your story and showcase your work! If your course checks, at minimum, all of the ★ (1-star) rating and ★★ (2-star) rating boxes of the Course Evaluation Checklist above, submit your course using this form for a chance to win some coveted Canvas SWAG! Winners will be announced and asked to write a short blog post showcasing their work and processes! Winning courses will be showcased by Instructure in demos and materials as best practice examples. I can’t wait to see the submissions, and I know the Canvas Community can’t wait either! In the meantime, in the comments, share what YOU look for when you evaluate courses. What does your institution prioritize? Do you have a review process? What do you find to be the most important aspects of Instructional Design or UDL? 

For more course design inspiration utilizing best practices, explore our Ready-Made Template Suite.  Our Instructional Design team offers templates, consultation, badging services, course evaluations, workshops, and more. Explore Instructure’s Learning Services that may be of interest to you or your organization.


Please comment below. We’d love to hear from you!


Our Instructional Design team offers templates, consultation, badging services, course evaluations, workshops, and more. If you would like to learn more about our services, please contact your CSM or @deonne_johnson, Manager, Learning Services, via


24 Replies

@kimberly_ellis First of all, this post is brilliant. I can't wait to participant. I definitely will share with my teachers and Canvas Coaches.

When I evaluate courses I look for the following:

  1. A simple, inviting landing page
  2. Ease of Navigation (the click of three rule)
  3. Accessible content
  4. Engaging and interactive uses of not only Canvas tools but also 3rd party resources

My district does not currently have a review process in place for academic course but that is something I am working toward. We do have a professional learning review process -- where I have modified the Course Evaluation Checklist for our professional learning instances.

I am building a course currently called Designing with a Purpose and in that course I want to provide our teachers with a deep understanding of UDL and Accessibility. These frameworks just make good sense, designing with the goal of making multiple means of representation, engagement, action and expression a priority so all students (and adults) have equal access.

Your work is always inspiring. Thanks for this exciting opportunity.


Hey @DonLourcey, thanks for your kind words and for sharing your processes and what you look for in ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑ courses!  I love that you are already using the Course Evaluation Checklist and have modified it to fit your specific PD needs!

So glad that you will submit your course(s) and share this opportunity with your teachers and Canvas Coaches! 

Community Contributor

This is just a great idea, Kimberly! I’m excited to spread the news of this and provide some opportunities for others to see what great resources y’all are providing!


@akinsey Hey friend!  Yes, please spread the word and submit your fabulous courses!! 

New Member

LOVE this and MISS you!!!!!!  

Community Member

Hi! I saw that entry requires submitting a link to our course. What will the folks reviewing submitted courses be able to see? I want to make sure my students’ information isn’t revealed in this process, if I participate. Thanks!

New Member

Love these ideas. At our K-12 institution, we evaluate courses according to 6 key ideas using a rubric and central survey form. We are continuing to use quality templates to drive these areas. 

  • Conceptual and physical navigation
  • How learning is evaluated
  • Embedded digital tool use and impact of technology 
  • Knowledge, understanding and skills
  • Facility for student engagement 
  • Evidence of differentiation 




Hi @hagranne!  With respects to your students' personal information, there is no requirement that you submit a link to a live course with student data. You could copy to a blank course in your institution's instance or in Free for Teacher. In any event, we won't share or ask you to share any part of your course containing sensitive information (as screenshots or otherwise). All contest reviewers will be employees of Instructure. Please let me know if you have questions about this.  We hope you participate!


@jlloyd thanks for sharing! I love that your institution has a rubric organized into these 6 key areas.  This makes it easy to identify needs for professional development!