cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Hidden Rubrics

Hidden Rubrics

(39)

Teachers need a toggle to hide rubrics till the teacher release it, a date, or when all students have submitted. I want to be to make an assignment where students complete it one day, and then the next day they are automatically assigned peer reviews and grade each other using the rubric.  Showing the rubric before hand is stupid and is odd that there is no option.  I do not want to have to go in every day and add a rubric.  I want to set it for each unit and just have to come in and check stats and add comments to responses.  

40 Comments
Stef_retired
Instructure Alumni
Instructure Alumni

Hello,  @matthew_heering  Welcome to the Canvas Community! The purpose of a rubric is to provide students with clear guidelines for completing their assignments, and here's one example of the research around that—so displaying the rubric to students ahead of time is intentional and by design.

That said, we have opened this idea for voting, and encourage you to support an idea that is more closely aligned with the peer review use case you've described: https://community.canvaslms.com/ideas/16149-rubrics  You might also want to vote up https://community.canvaslms.com/ideas/1988-add-multiple-rubrics-to-one-assignment .

Thanks.

jenacal
New Member

I'd appreciate this option as well.  For example: If I can have students peer review one another's comprehension quizzes this both 1) frees me up to do more in-depth comments on other elements of the course and 2) reinforces the material by having them "teach" it themselves.

 

 

jessica422
Community Member

@Stef_retired ,

While it is good for students to have access to rubrics, I usually provide those beforehand with the instructions for the assignment. In previous LMS, such as blackboard, I used the rubric feature to grade. I broke down the rubric I gave students elsewhere and for each section in the online speedgrader rubric attached to the assignment, I added the answers and then used the scoring feature to grade via the in-site rubric. I want to use the rubric in Canvas the same way. However, because Canvas refuses to allow us to hide the rubric, that means students can see the answers. The rubric feature is pointless if I cannot use it assist with grading by entering the answers in each section to more quickly and efficiently enter points they earned. Unless I want to last-minute create a rubric with the answers, I now have to spend more time and effort looking back and forth from answers that I have elsewhere to the student's assignment instead of being able to see everything in the same screen. Again, I have never in my life met a teacher that did not provide a rubric or instructions with an assignment. Students do not NEED to see the rubric in Canvas that we're using to grade with because we can and often do provide it elsewhere, and a lot of people use it list answers to assignments to more efficiently and quickly grade in speedgrader. Please add an option to hide the rubric from students. I can't even have the luxury of adding a rubric to use with grading last minute because some students turn work in late. Essentially, I cannot use the rubric for grading in the most efficient way at all until all people have turned in their assignment, which really holds up grading.

sraeker-jordan
New Member

Could you please allow the instructor to attach a rubric to an assignment and HIDE IT from students until the instructor is ready to reveal it? I would like to start grading assignment submissions as they come in, but I cannot do so until after the deadline when they are all submitted (105 of them). Otherwise, students will see the rubric and the "answers," when the assignment is meant to assess them on what they can do on their own. Thanks.

JTipping
New Member

I completely agree with @matthew_heering@jessica422 and @sraeker-jordan in that we also share clear rubric and success criteria prior to the assignment and therefore use the rubrics feature to support with providing feedback. 

Ideally I would be able to have a Rubric of "What Went Wells", positive achieved criteria visible during the assignment for students to challenge themselves to achieve and then a private/unpublished rubric that I could then unhide/activate after submission that contains detailed pre-written feedback for each question. But I currently don't want students to access the latter prior to the assignment being submitted. 

Dustin2000
New Member

I think my issue is that there are only 2 ways to really grade work. Rubric or create something as quiz. If I want to grade something as a basic right/wrong, I cannot put the answer key into a rubric because the students see it. If I could hide the rubric, then I can grade simply assignments while having the answer key and mark correct/incorrect responses all in one.

lanthanide
New Member

While I understand the comments above that a rubric is meant to guide students and indicate how they will be evaluated, I want to recapitulate what others are saying that it would be a useful feature in Speedgrader/Canvas to be able to append the Rubric with correct answers/sample work to use it as a grading guide and an answer key for after the assignment has been turned in. Doesn't matter if this is an added feature to Rubrics or a different feature altogether, I think most of the people above are asking for this to help with grading efficiency, not in the transparency and inclusiveness of their classrooms (which can be improved through sharing a rubric.) Thanks for the consideration for this feature!

Econgrad
New Member

Yes, the feature needs to be implemented immediately.  It is creating so much confusion among my students.  I grade question by question and update the rubric for each student as I progress through.  If grades are hidden then so should rubric comments and points.

trolson
Community Participant

Can I vote on this?

YES this needs to be addressed!  If a RUBRIC the only grading mechanism in SpeedGrader, then either MAKE IT MORE FLEXIBLE for grading applications or INTRODUCE a NEW GRADING/SCORING TOOL.

SusanNiemeyer
Community Contributor

I, too, want to HIDE my rubrics until my students have completed by assignment. Each of my rubrics is specific to the content of the students' reading assignments. If the students access the rubrics ahead of time, they will see the answers! All we need is a little box to check mark. 

EStinkens
New Member

I completely agree with @lanthanide . Please add the feature so that teachers can choose how they want to use rubrics

CJHerman
New Member

Yes, the ability to hide rubrics is desperately needed.

SusanNiemeyer
Community Contributor

Here's a workaround for "hiding" the ratings section of a rubric.

If you click on "I'll write free-form comments when assessing students," the students will see be able to see the criteria, but they won't see the descriptions of the ratings. 

I use this workaround for rubrics which contain the answers in the ratings boxes. I just unclick that box once the students have submitted their work and I'm ready to grade their assignments.

EF1
Community Member

The issue is not if students need to see a rubric - of course they should.

But when you use it to grade an assignment the marks within the rubric should be hidden by the 'Hide Grades' option, just as the total mark is hidden. Otherwise the Hide Grades function doesn't actually hide the grades - students can see their mark by clicking on the rubric. Students should continue to see the ungraded rubric until such time as you 'Post Marks' then they can see the graded rubric.

EF1
Community Member

Actually, there is a kind of work around by using the "Hide score total for assessment results" when you are first setting up a rubric. This means the total mark for each rubric criteria is hidden for the student but you can still use it to grade the assignment.

Screen Shot 2021-03-17 at 9.57.41 am.png

jessica422
Community Member

This hides scores for the rubric, not the rubric itself. As stated previously, many of us put answers in the rubric when we create it to use for grading. For example, question number 1 is a point. I enter "answer is 5" for question number one on the rubric so that when I'm grading, I can look at the rubric and their answer and give them a point if they entered "5". Students can still see the rubric and whatever you put into it even if they can't see the scores you give them on the rubric, so this does not work. They can see that I wrote "the answer is 5" in the rubric even if they do not see that I gave them a point.

jessica422
Community Member

You're missing the point entirely. Many of us want a function where we can enter the answers in an easily viewable place to have accessible while we are grading so that we do not have to look back and forth between an answer sheet and what students entered for their answer. We can look directly at the rubric where we've written the answer and provide points within that same rubric. Rubrics/instructions for students can easily be provided elsewhere for students to access - such as in the assignment itself either pasted into the page or as a file they can download. They do not need to see the answer key. Many of us want an answer key function in canvas and are asking canvas to either have an option to hide rubrics when we want to use it as an answer again (again, we can provide the rubric without answers as a file or something for students), or to create a new answer key function for grading. If we can allow students to view their answers on quizzes without showing them the correct answer, we should have the same function available for assignments.

cdona
New Member

Having to wait for everyone to submit their assignments before I can begin grading is a real pain.  Please give the option for instructors to use rubrics for grading while HIDDEN and then be able to publish them when grading has been completed.

SusanNiemeyer
Community Contributor

cdona,

I have figured out how to hide the ratings descriptions before I start grading. (Click on "I'll write free-form when assessing students.") However, in order to start grading, I have to remove that check mark, which means that any student can now read the rubric.

While I'm grading, I both "hide" the grades and set the grading policy policy to "manual" to keep the students from seeing their scores. (Both steps are necessary.) However, the rubric itself is now viewable to all students.

Alas, I don't think it's possible for you to hide the rubric once you've started using it to grade your students' work.

It apparently never occurred to the Canvas developers that some teachers would like to use rubrics as "answer keys." 

 

MichaelJanas
New Member

To provide another reason why such a feature is needed: With the Canvas rubric in its present functionality, the only way to use a detailed Canvas rubric to grade exam problems without revealing this same rubric to the makeup students is to wait until all students have submitted. But exams often give alternative hours for students with conflicts or disability accomodations, and this can require waiting multiple days due to scheduling. Given the pace at which final exams in particular have to be graded, this renders such Canvas rubrics all but useless.