cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Module Progress Bar (amended)

Module Progress Bar (amended)

(12)

Amended after comments and questions from  @James ‌.

TL;DR

Instructors should be able to add a module progress bar
Amendment: Instructors should be able to add a module progress bar that includes the module title.

Why it's needed

Students benefit from web pages that are shorter rather than longer, and as a consequence Modules can have many links within. In one of my courses there are anywhere from 8 to 20 items in each of 12 modules. That's a lot of clicking Next and Previous for my students! Each begins with an overview and ends with a summary, but there is no progress report within each module unless I add one on each page. It would be great if one could be there automatically so when I reorder items or add or remove things the progress bar is updated without me needing to make edits there.

Amendment: While students are navigating through a module, the title of the module does not appear on the page with the exception of external links. For those module items it appears in the breadcrumbs, but the breadcrumbs for other module item include the name of the tool instead (Pages, Discussions, Quizzes, etc.). Since each module has an anchor link on the Modules page, it would also be great if the title of the module, hyperlinked to that module's anchor on the Modules page, appeared as part of the progress bar.

How it will work

Instructors will have the option to add an automatically generated progress bar at the bottom of each page that is part of a module, between the Previous and Next buttons. The option for a progress bar will be module by module, and it will appear on every published item within that module. (That's a bonus way to communicate the item's published status to instructors!) 

Amendment: The progress bar will include the title of the module hyperlinked to the module's anchor on the Modules page. 

The progress bar will show the count of published items within the module and the number of the current item (e.g., 1 out of 12, 2 out of 12, etc.). It might look like the heart rate tracker on my favorite elliptical trainer at my gym:

heart rate tracker

I propose numbers instead of words, but it might be neat if it ended with "PEAK LEARNING." :smileycool:

How this benefits students

Students benefit from knowing where they are within a module. This helps them plan their time on task, especially for those modules that are structured consistently. It is good for them to know how many times they have to select that Next link before they achieve peak learning.

Amendment: And as awesome as our module titles are, our students might forget which module they are in. Including the module title as part of the progress tracker will help them stay aware of their surroundings.

21 Comments
klundstrum
Community Coach
Community Coach

This is a neat idea! I've seen instructors/designers do this by hand with images, but each time something is added, deleted, or reorganized, that image needs to be replaced or adjusted! I wonder if this could be a course-level option, but I would definitely like to add an option like this to my modules.

I look forward to seeing others' contributions to this conversation! Smiley Happy

James
Navigator

 @GregoryBeyrer ,

Interesting concept.

Someone asked me a week or two ago about determining progress in a module. My first response to her was to ask how she would measure progress since that would drive how I answered her.

How do you envision measuring progress? Do you treat every item in the module as an equal percentage of the overall goal, just count the quizzes and assignments but not reading, external items, just consider the items that appear in the module requirements (similar to a graphical version of the "View Progress" button), or something else?

GregoryBeyrer
Adventurer III

Great question,  @James . To me it's just a link counter. I don't imagine the amount of time or effort on an individual item to be represented on the tracker; some students will of course spend more time or effort on some items and more on others. I for example spend more time reading your posts and contributions than I do on those from others. This would be separate from the module requirements, to-do items, assignment submissions, etc.

ken_cooper
Surveyor

 @GregoryBeyrer ‌ and  @James ‌ -- since I did upvote, I wanted to comment that I would hope it would just be a raw counter.  For modules grades I could see it being weighted, as grades are weighted and the calculations are right there (not saying that we need a progress bar for both though), but for this idea I was under the assumption it was a pure tracker of activity done in a module.  I don't think faculty members are going to want to setup weighting for those activities and sub-activities in many cases, and the amount of overhead to maintain that from term-to-term when adding/removing/editing resources would just be too great.

GideonWilliams
Adventurer II

Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes please

James
Navigator

Are they discrete bars that can also serve as a jump to that item? Of course, one would have to have tooltips so people knew what they were.

I know this is not the same thing that you're talking about, but I have a table of contents menu bar at the bottom of one of my courses. It displays the chapter in green and then expands the chapter that we're currently on black with the section that we're currently one in blue.

312041_pastedImage_1.png

That works because the course is highly structured, but I've only applied it to lecture notes. I don't know how much the students use it, but I wanted to make it friendly for them to see where they are.

What you're talking about would be just the section I have coded in black / blue, but you couldn't put text on them because it would be too big and if a module had lots of items in it, then it would take a lot of space. A percentage or scaled meter would be the only way to go. 

I'm guessing that extended thought suggests that you should not make them hyperlinks, but I'm not sure. Keyboard users and people using screen readers probably don't want to listen to a list of all of the modules.

But that makes me wonder about a select box that would allow the user to list all of the items in a module and let them quick jump to the one they wanted.

That's not really what you wanted, I'm just thinking out loud (metaphorically, of course).

ken_cooper
Surveyor

Wow  @James , that's really cool.  Is that a Canvancement, or just something that you custom built for your course?  For a course with a good deal of module content items it would be really nice to be able to quick jump from within one module page/activity to another without having to go back to the modules page.  If I could go from 12.3 to 12.18 right from 12.3 for instance, would be a nice time saver.  Not trying to derail the topic, as this isn't really the same thing as Greg's idea, but I love the functionality you're showing right here.

GregoryBeyrer
Adventurer III

Thinking out loud is awesome. No, my intent would not be for hyperlinks. I wouldn't want students to jump through the module out of the sequence I have set up. If I have requirements set up that won't be a problem; if I don't then I'd rather students have to look at the titles of all the module items before they select where they want to go. They can see those titles on the Modules page. And the potential for lots of module items is another good reason to make the progress bar be simple with just a few pieces of information that can work regardless of the number of items in the module:

<--Previous | Item no. X out of Y | Next-->

James
Navigator

That's some PHP code I threw together that loads the page, appends/replaces the menu bar, and then writes it back if it has changed the page. I have a very structured naming system:

Chapter 3 Introduction, Chapter 4 Introduction, Chapter 5 Introduction, etc.,

Chapter 3 Summary, Chapter 4 Summary, Chapter 5 Summary, etc.,

Section 3.1, Section 3.2, Section 3.3, etc.

The code isn't published anywhere. It uses an unpublished PHP API I wrote.

James
Navigator

Just documenting some things ...

The Get module item sequence endpoint of the Modules API accepts two parameters. The values that we would most likely want are:

  • asset_type = ModuleItem
  • asset_id = the module_item_id that appears in the URL

If you specify a module item id, then items will only be in one module, so you don't have to worry about duplicate modules.

This returns an object with an items array. The items[0].current.position contains the position of the current module. This would satisfy the X portion of "Item no. X out of Y."

A second property is the modules array. Again, there is just one when you specify the module item id. The modules[0].items_count contains the total number of items in the module. This would provide the Y portion of "Item no. X out of Y."

In other words, only one API call is needed per module item to determine the information needed. This is the same call that Canvas makes to fetch the previous and next buttons, although it adds an undocumented frame_external_urls=true query parameter.

The modules[0] object also includes the name of the module that you're in. I mention this because I'm a little wary of the language "Item no. X of Y" and whether it conveys what we want conveyed in an unconfusing way. It doesn't mention that it's the current module and someone might reasonable take it to mean something else. I imagine Greg was mentioning that just as an example, but the wording should be flexed out if someone wants to write code that would do this before Canvas gets around to it.

The content is contained in a div with id="sequence_footer" but more specifically in a div inside that with a class="module-sequence-footer-content"

Edit: It appears that the parent div changes depending on what kind of content it is, so we may have to look for the class rather than an CSS id.

GregoryBeyrer
Adventurer III

James, you are amazing and absolutely correct about the language. I thought about including the module title in that sample text (perhaps "[Module Title] item no. X out of Y") except that the title might be too long to include. After reading your message about the potential for missed meaning and remembering that the module title appears nowhere on the page (except for external links), I decided to amend my idea to add the module title linked to its anchor on the Modules page. 

Your comments helped make a better idea!

James
Navigator

I think and ellipses (CSS overflow) could be used to handle the long modules names. I would put the module name last, that way they can still see the counts if it gets cut off.

Perhaps one of these?

  • Item 13 out of 15 in module: Chapter 5 Geometric Approach to Linear Programming
  • Item 13 out of 15 in the Chapter 5 Geometric Approach to Linear Programming module
  • Item 13 out of 15 in Chapter 5 Geometric Approach to Linear Programming
  • Item 13 out of 15 in module

The last one is a throwback to your original idea, just so people could see how it would look without the name there.

I'm also thinking that the name of the module should link to the module. The module_id is contained in the API response, so it could be formed rather easily.

I wouldn't add that to the feature request, though. Canvas asks us not to get overly prescriptive in the ideas. I'm just doing more of my thinking out loud.

Hopefully there will be more thinking out loud, I've got all my finals made up, there's just one more day of classes before finals start, and I'm taking the summer off teaching for the first time since starting teaching. I have other duties besides teaching to work on, but I feel much lighter than I have in a while.

tdwightminister
Surveyor

Yeeeeees!!!!!

timothy_maw
Adventurer

This would be fantastic for us as we are a competency-based institution. Making it so students can see exactly where they are at in a module would really help them to track their progress.

ehouswor
Surveyor

The administration here has been offering very glossy online "courses" - career planning for undergraduates (good, I took part of it and it told me to be what I am and what I love being) and teaching improvement courses for faculty (not so good - regions of a Venn diagram "interject.") But those courses have lovely progress bars. The bars are images that are created specifically for the modules/pages in the course and inserted as appropriate in each page. I have been wondering whether it would be worth it to spend the time creating that eye candy for my online course and ran across the idea on this page when I was searching about ways to do it in Canvas. It would be lovely if Canvas just did it in a reasonable fashion. 

dominiquel
Surveyor II

Oh yes, that would be awesome! Our students used to have a progress bar for each course they were enrolled to - visible on the dashboard, back in Moodle. They are missing it terribly!

It's a great way to see how much more they've got to do. It would even be awesome to have a timer till the end of the term to show them exactly how much they've got left until a specific date. Heart

GideonWilliams
Adventurer II

Agree, the Moodle progress bar was an awesome feature. Multi functional too.

mhouser20
Surveyor

I have a suggestion. One thing that frustrates me about Canvas modules, once I'm working in the module, is not knowing how much I have left to complete it. I suggest putting page numbers in a module (1 of 5, for example) so that students can see how many parts they have accomplished and what they have left in a module.

jmohr1
Surveyor

With the transition to online learning, we're using modules A LOT more than before. This is resulting in a very clunky Canvas experience and difficulty organizing stuff (I have seen Idea Conversations for better page and module management, but this request touches on a third feature I would like to see).

We use modules to organize labs, lectures, and studios in their own modules each week. Some modules can get very long and become tedious to navigate, since you can only use the "Next" and "Previous" buttons to navigate the modules. So if you want to go back to a specific page within a module, you either need to load many pages or go back to the modules page and locate the page you want. It would be super convenient to have a right-hand navigation bar always visible that organizes and structures the module (with the indents as it appears on the module page). That way students can jump around the module a little more easily and check their overall progress.

mrwnphs2
Surveyor II

Agree with @jmohr1