OK, the white rocket ship is the Classic Quiz engine. Are all the questions organized into a Question Group, by any chance? If they are, you'll see a heading above the questions that says "Group" (or whatever someone decided to name the group), followed by "Pick X questions, X pts per question." If you're seeing that, that means the questions have been put in a group, which are always randomized no matter what—you can't override the randomization of question groups by turning off shuffle. Unfortunately the only solution is rewriting the quiz by clicking "New Question" every time instead of "New Question Group."
If you're not seeing that, then something else might be going on, but that's my initial hunch.
This discussion post is outdated and has been archived. Please use the Community question forums and official documentation for the most current and accurate information.