As a Solutions Engineer, my days are spent troubleshooting problems and testing solutions. I like gathering information and analyzing data — so, it's no wonder I like detective shows, especially the classics, like Kojak, in the gritty streets of Manhattan, and Hawaii Five-O action on sunny island shores. I appreciate the strategy that goes into solving a crime, cracking a case, and putting things right.
In my work, I'm often asked what I think is the best solution for content authoring and course design. Well, I always say the best solutions are the ones that fit the organization and their goals. This could include anything from SCORM authoring to native LMS content creation, with the ideal choice being the one that best supports the needs and interests of the people enrolled in the courses.
I know, I know. SCORM and Canvas? Really? Yes! Canvas and SCORM are not competitors, but partners—much like the team on Hawaii Five-O. You’ve got experienced Captain Steve McGarrett, Danny "Danno" Williams, a young recruit fresh off the mainland, and local expert detectives Chin Ho Kelly and Kono Kalakaua. They're a state police squad that works independently but in collaboration with the Honolulu Police Department.
Similarly, in Canvas, we blend local content created within Canvas with imported resources. These elements are valuable individually, but together, they create perfect harmony, like McGarrett’s team and the Honolulu PD.
SCORM
Over twelve seasons of Hawaii Five-O we saw McGarrett's wardrobe metamorphosis, but the show's formula stayed true: crime strikes, Five-O investigates, justice prevails. Book 'em, Danno.
Likewise, SCORM authoring tools and output styles have changed over the years, but the core framework remains: digital learning objects with video, text, and interactives. SCORM objects are designed for portability, so learners get a consistent experience: click, watch, read, respond, done, no matter where they access the content. But SCORM is more than just basic materials; it supports interactive elements like simulations and games – something most LMS struggle to provide.
LMS Content
Canvas is a versatile platform for creating a wide range of content types. With Canvas Modules, instructors can easily incorporate text, images, videos, and interactive elements into a clear, elegant learning pathway. The native LMS content within modules is easily editable and all content can be reordered and sequenced with requirements and prerequisites for learners to follow.
Rather than choosing one or the other, interactive SCORM elements can be incorporated into the Canvas content for a richer learning experience.
The SCORM Conundrum
SCORM packages are like sealed boxes. They get exported from the tool you create them in, as a zipped file, and then uploaded into Canvas. If you spot a tiny typo or want to change anything at all, you can't just fix it. You have to go back to the original source file in the authoring tool, make a change, export and reimport to an LMS. That's a lot of steps for one little fix!
Native LMS content is easy to change. With Canvas it's much simpler. You can edit text, images, videos—everything—right there in Canvas. No extra tools or re-uploading needed. Easy-peasy.
Consider releasing the longer narrative content from the SCORM package and building it in the LMS. Use SCORM for what it does best - the interactive components that can be used strategically to break up the monotony of reading and watching video, or used to allow learners to practice a skill in a digital simulation. Use the LMS features for the didactics, peer to peer interactions, coaching elements, and assessments.
This way, you get the best of both worlds: the ease of editing in Canvas and the engaging power of SCORM. It keeps things fresh and interesting for learners as they work through modules and interact with LMS native content and with SCORM activities. You, the creator, can track progress through all content - Canvas and SCORM components - within Canvas.
And now, for the dramatic conclusion
In the end, just like McGarrett and his team, the best approach to online learning often involves a strategic partnership. By thoughtfully blending Canvas and SCORM, we can craft a seamless and immersive journey. Canvas provides the organized framework and easy editing, while SCORM brings in those engaging, interactive elements. It’s not about choosing sides; it’s about finding the perfect blend.
So, as you design your courses, remember that both Canvas and SCORM have valuable roles to play. By leveraging their individual strengths and fostering a collaborative environment, you can create a truly dynamic and effective learning experience. Now, go forth and build your own palm-tree laden tropical learning paradise!
|
Feature |
Canvas |
SCORM |
|
Content Management |
Supports diverse content (text, files, videos) and collaboration (discussions, projects, live conferencing) |
Best for independent learning activities, interactive eLearning (simulations, games) |
|
Editing |
Quick and easy, in Canvas |
Complex; requires authoring tool edits, re-exporting, and re-uploading. |
|
Interactivity |
Ideal for shared learning experiences – peer-to-peer learning, mentoring and coaching |
Best for self-paced interactive elements; self knowledge checks; simulations |
|
Sequencing, Rules |
Flexible sequencing and granular control |
Standard click-through sequencing and tracking. |
|
Progress Tracking |
Tracks progress through various Canvas content and activities. |
Tracks progress within the SCORM object; data passes to Canvas gradebook. |
Canvas Resources
- How do I add course content as module items?
- How do I move or reorder a module item?
- How do I use modules to view the progress of students in a course?
- How do I import SCORM files as an assignment?
- How do I import SCORM files as a page?
- Student view: How do I view Modules as a student?
Hawaii Five-O Resources
- Wikipedia: Hawaii Five-O (1968 TV series)
- Image source: Musings (of a retired school teacher) Blog
