Eliminate the playwalls in the Community

Problem statement:

We are six months into our transition to Canvas. The user community was touted as a "great resource" for new ideas and features. I am regularly finding issues such as the ability to hide grading rubrics from students and the inability to only allow student graders to see the assignment they are grading, while hiding the rest of the gradebook from them. I am able to see that these are ideas that have been in the ideas queue since 2020, but I am unable to upvote or comment on them or describe the impact on our campus because Community roles prohibit me from doing so because I haven't participated in the community enough. Maybe. I can't be sure, because all I see is that each community level has unspecified "elevated permissions". I'm currently frantically working on building a process so that I can collect student performance grades from second year students who are reviewing first year students. I'm building this in Microsoft Forms and will need to reformat this file to import it into the gradebook and capture the comments properly. I can't use the Canvas rubric for this because if graders have access to grade anything, they have access to the entire gradebook which is a MASSIVE FERPA violation. But I can't discuss this in the appropriate idea thread because I'm trying to support my users, not waste time becoming Internet famous on this board.

Proposed solution:

Eliminate all permissions breaks above community member, or explicitly state which permissions are necessary for each level.

User role(s):

admin,designer

13 Comments
SteveWeidner
Community Participant
Author

Correction: Eliminate all permissions above Community EXPLORER, or explicitly state which permissions are necessary for each level.

SteveWeidner
Community Participant
Author

Funny thing about arbitrary playwalls: If you make users jump through hoops to be able to do their job, they may just cut down the hoops.

 

SteveWeidner
Community Participant
Author

Because when you insist they post a bunch of times, they may just end up replying to their own posts to meet that arbitrary roadblock. 

SteveWeidner
Community Participant
Author

Or start liking everything they can see and thus destroy any value you claim to be creating with this "curation".

SteveWeidner
Community Participant
Author

You also realize that people can just log out and in again to get over that whole "total logins" requirement?

SteveWeidner
Community Participant
Author

But if you want to know which Idea I'm talking about with hiding the gradebook, this one was posted in 2021 and was apparently reopened last year.

SteveWeidner
Community Participant
Author

And hey, I'm good to keep posting on my own thread to hit whatever new arbitrary threshold you gave me.

ModeratorPanda
Community Team
Community Team
Status changed to: Seeking Clarity

Thank you for your idea submission. You mention two different areas: how the Community functions and how the Gradebook functions. Both interests are important, and the development team can work better if ideas are more focused. This idea submission will benefit by recommending a single change, and you are encouraged to submit separate ideas for separate changes.

As we wait for a reply with further information, we’re placing your request in the Seeking Clarity status for two weeks. Please respond by Sep. 1 so we can provide your idea the attention it deserves. If you are unable to reply by then, we’ll Archive the thread to allow the Product Team to focus on newer requests.

SteveWeidner
Community Participant
Author

This is about how the community functions. Which would have been obvious to a human. 

SteveWeidner
Community Participant
Author

Yet another example of an AI just making things worse.