Canvas Rubric for Quizzes/Exams?

[MingleDynasty24]

Hello, Everyone!

I am relatively new to being a Canvas administrator, and I have an instructor who would like to add rubrics to their quizzes/exams. They want to add a rubric to a 10-question/20-point multiple-choice quiz. Would there be any benefit to adding a rubric to this quiz? From my understanding, the quiz is automatically graded and entered into the gradebook. A rubric would not serve a purpose in this context, correct? The instructor would be better off explaining the expectations of the quiz in the directions. 

Secondly, regarding the exams, the instructor is teaching a face-to-face class but wants to create a rubric in Canvas for the 100-point exams students will take on paper. Would a rubric make any sense in this context? Thank you all in advance! 

[NoahBoswell · Accepted solution]

Hey @MingleDynasty24 ,

You are correct, the scores from the Canvas quizzes are automatically entered into the Canvas gradebook, and then with a lot of schools who have a SIS connected it can be synced directly over to that gradebook as well.

I’ve personally never heard of a teacher using rubrics for quizzes, at least at our school (we are K12), that is not a common practice at all. Our teachers usually explain their expectations and other information in the quiz directions before the students take their quiz, or provide additional information once the student reaches a specific question on the quiz. But yeah, we have never ever used rubrics for quizzes, since quizzes can be automatically graded and are entered into the canvas gradebook seamlessly.

I hope this helps a bit!

- Noah

[MingleDynasty24]

@noah ,

Thank you for your timely response! I appreciate your help. I found the instructor's question rather odd, but I wanted to ensure that I didn't advise them incorrectly if there was an efficient way to make rubrics work for an exam/quiz. I will recommend our instructor that the directions will be the best place to instruct students. Thank you! 

[James]

@MingleDynasty24 

Rubrics certainly can have a roll on Canvas quizzes and on paper exams as well.

For quizzes, grades are automatically populated by the score on the quiz. However, you can still complete a rubric for the quiz. One use is for outcomes tracking. Rubrics can incorporate outcomes, so if your quiz is assessing one of the outcomes, it makes absolute sense to track it right there in the quiz.

For paper exams, I use a rubric with a criteria for each question. I go through and rate each question as Awesome, Good, Okay, Fair, Poor, or None. Those are the only six possibilities for each question. The ratings are based on did they get the right answer with sufficient work (I teach math), the right answer without enough work, ..., down to you're nowhere close or you left the problem blank.

From the student's perspective, they can look at the rubric before the exam and know that question (for example) #3 is worth 40% of the test so they better focus on that while #10 is only worth 5% so they don't need to stress as much over that.

When I grade the tests, I use the rubric for scoring. Once entered, students can see how they did on each question rather than just an overall score of say 87.62%.

We also collect outcomes from test questions (we're in the process of switching over to using rubrics) to report. By having a rubric for each I want to record, I can give the tests back to the students but still have a record of the results I need for the outcomes process. I don't have to make copies of every student's quiz or write down the scores to questions 5, 6, 10, and 11. It's already recorded in the rubric.

In another case, I use a quiz to generate a rubric that is then attached to another assessment. I allow students to design their own research project given some constraints. They enter their choices into a Canvas quiz and then I read the answers, check to see if there will be problems, and complete a rubric on another assignment to give them feedback. I do that in two assignments because I want them to get credit for completing the quiz (so I use a graded survey), but I don't want them to get the go-ahead until the data is going to work, so I make the second assignment complete/incomplete.

You absolutely do not have to make a rubric for the exam (unless required by some school policy), but they can be reasons for using them. Others have more in-depth use cases than I do and some want the ability to attach a rubric to an individual question rather than to the whole quiz. Rubric usage varies a lot, which is part of why it's hard to find a solution that works for everyone.

Based on what your instructor wrote, it sounds like a "Do I have to make a rubric for the exam?" question. No, but in that instructor's mind, they might be asking if they need to go through and put thought into each question and decide how much each question is worth ahead of time. In that case, the answer is yes and a rubric -- or a study guide -- could help. If it was a multi-section, multi-instructor course or a large course with lots of TA's doing the grading, then having a rubric of how to grade could be invaluable. That doesn't seem to be the case here, but just more reasons why someone would want to have a rubric.

If the questions were essay rather than multiple-choice, then a grading rubric is a great idea.

[JonBerry]

As @James stated, rubrics do have a use in quizzes--mainly on free response questions.

I noticed that you stated the quiz had 10 questions and was worth a total of 20 points... Is that 2 points per question, or are different questions worth different points? Does each question have a "best" answer and an "okay" answer in addition to incorrect answers? If that's the case, Canvas has the options to give each answer an individual point weight, as well as automated grading feedback for each answer and for the question as a whole.

I wouldn't consider the different point values a rubric, but I can see how others might.

Varied Points Example: