Hi @PamelaMelone -
After some digging and some help from an amazing Community member, I think I have something that will fix this for you.
In How do I use the Total column in the Gradebook?, there is a line in the top box that says: When assignment groups are weighted, points cannot be displayed for the total grade.
So, we need to open Assignments, then adjust Weighted Grades. That box must be unchecked for there to be an option in the Total Grades column to display as points.
I hope this is what you're looking for! Please update the Community once you have time to work in you r course.