Rubric Comment Library

[heather_monti]

Hi there,

 

I recently received this email from one of our faculty:

 

Am I understanding this correctly?   

 

In the spring I was using rubrics that didn't show points values to students, just comments.    And speedgrader offered to set up a library of comments, one for each criterion.

 

 

 

 

Now I'm using a rubric that does show points values, and the comments library feature seems to have gone away.

 

 

[YasiAfsharnive]

Hi @heather_monti! Great questions!

We’ve made some small experience updates with Enhanced Rubrics:

• Comment Library: You can access the comment library in SpeedGrader by clicking the small icon above the submission comments box. From there, you can create new comments or insert existing ones into the assignment.

• Removing Points from Rubrics: To remove points, open the rubric editor and either select the “Unscored” option or choose “Hide total points from students” depending on your preferred experience.

Let us know if you need help finding these settings or have more feedback!

[heather_monti]

@YasiAfsharnive Thank you for your quick response, but unfortunately, it doesn't answer my questions.  Currently, the Comment Library is available in each rubric criterion for unscored rubrics, however, the Comment Library is not available in any rubric criterion for scored rubrics.  

I'm not referring to the Comment Library in Speedgrader for the overall assignment.

Is it possible to have a Comment Library available in each rubric criterion for a scored rubric?  Thanks!

[YasiAfsharnive]

@heather_monti Got it, thanks for clarifying. You are correct, the Comment Library is available for individual rubric criteria when you're using written feedback (such as text-only, unscored criteria). However, when you're grading on a scale (such as using rating levels to assign points), the Comment Library is not currently available within each criterion.

This is due to the different interaction models: rating-based criteria are designed for quick point selection, while written feedback supports more open-ended responses, which is where the Comment Library is integrated.

We know this is a limitation for instructors who want to reuse comments while still using scored rubrics, and it’s something we’re actively considering for future iterations. Really appreciate you surfacing this!

[heather_monti]

Thank you, I really appreciate the consideration for a future iteration.