@RyanHolloway ...
Thanks for the extra detail. If you are experiencing an error like that, I would recommend reaching out to Canvas Support ... as they would be better able to take a look at your Canvas account to see what might be going on. To contact Support, click on the "Help" icon on the far left-hand global navigation menu in Canvas, and then "Report a Problem". It helps to be on the page where you are experiencing the issue before clicking on this "Report a Problem" link...because it will send some additional metadata with your ticket. Someone from Canvas Support should get back to you soon.
How do I contact Canvas Support? and How do I get help with Canvas? - Instructure Community - 618758
Good luck, and please report back as you hopefully get this resolved.